Books read for May:
29 May 2010 18:46![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
cog_nomen-Seaward
-The Ice Palace Murders
-The Beekeeper's Apprentice
-Justice at Risk
-Sherlock Holmes, The Veiled Detective
Total: 24
Very nearly halfway to my goal! Which is good because I may have to slow down for final fantasy big bang.
Seaward-
Cute. Short. A bit dated, but still an excellent piece of young adult fiction.
The Ice Palace Murders-
A Holmes that is much too sharp and poor mannered for my liking, but not a bad mystery overall. I enjoyed the original characters, and it seemed like the setting was well researched - everything was easy to visualize. Sadly, I have two more Holmes novels to read by this author, so I suppose I'll try to get them out of the way sooner rather than later, since I'm not crazy about this guy's depiction of Holmes.
The Beekeeper's Apprentice-
It's frustrating that this author is so good and yet suffers so badly from Mary Sueism. Her Holmes is fantastic, she's a bit unkind to Watson which loses her points. The female lead who she is romantically setting up with holmes at a third his age makes me want to vomit. In and of herself, it's not too bad, but may/december romances are so far from being 'my thing' that they make me queasy. I wish this could just be like an uncle/niece relationship so that I could read the rest of these books. Also the inclusion of Moriarty's supergenius daughter trying to blow everyone up for revenge is a bit... okay, yeah.
Justice at Risk-
Total fluff. Fun fluff, at least. I tore through it in just a couple days, as I usually do with Ben Justice books. I'm still trying to decide if I should keep them or if I'll probably never read them again.
The Veiled Detective-
Juvenile. Quick, but very bad. An alternate take on Study in Scarlet through The Final Problem/Empty House. A poor idea badly executed.
-The Ice Palace Murders
-The Beekeeper's Apprentice
-Justice at Risk
-Sherlock Holmes, The Veiled Detective
Total: 24
Very nearly halfway to my goal! Which is good because I may have to slow down for final fantasy big bang.
Seaward-
Cute. Short. A bit dated, but still an excellent piece of young adult fiction.
The Ice Palace Murders-
A Holmes that is much too sharp and poor mannered for my liking, but not a bad mystery overall. I enjoyed the original characters, and it seemed like the setting was well researched - everything was easy to visualize. Sadly, I have two more Holmes novels to read by this author, so I suppose I'll try to get them out of the way sooner rather than later, since I'm not crazy about this guy's depiction of Holmes.
The Beekeeper's Apprentice-
It's frustrating that this author is so good and yet suffers so badly from Mary Sueism. Her Holmes is fantastic, she's a bit unkind to Watson which loses her points. The female lead who she is romantically setting up with holmes at a third his age makes me want to vomit. In and of herself, it's not too bad, but may/december romances are so far from being 'my thing' that they make me queasy. I wish this could just be like an uncle/niece relationship so that I could read the rest of these books. Also the inclusion of Moriarty's supergenius daughter trying to blow everyone up for revenge is a bit... okay, yeah.
Justice at Risk-
Total fluff. Fun fluff, at least. I tore through it in just a couple days, as I usually do with Ben Justice books. I'm still trying to decide if I should keep them or if I'll probably never read them again.
The Veiled Detective-
Juvenile. Quick, but very bad. An alternate take on Study in Scarlet through The Final Problem/Empty House. A poor idea badly executed.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 6 Jun 2010 04:37 (UTC)Still, much thanks. I didn't even know there was a L/R LJ community! I didn't think it was big enough to have one. *laughs*